CARIBBEAN FINANCE CENTERS
Recent changes are helping the venerable finance centers of the Caribbean stave off increasingly intense international competition.
The changes have taken place just in time for the Caribbean centers, which have been feeling the heat of intensifying competition from new financial centers sprouting up around the globe.
One of the advantages of the Caribbean’s financial centers—as well as Bermuda, which is commonly grouped with the Caribbean centers—is that they are well established. “There are no major surprises in the region. It offers stability,” says Olga Kalinina, credit analyst in the sovereign ratings group at Standard & Poor’s in New York. “There is a strong institutional framework and policy predictability. Investors know that this will not change. There won’t be any nationalizations.”
But officials in this diverse group of more than two-dozen islands, stretching from Bermuda in the north Atlantic to Trinidad and Tobago in the southern Caribbean, have their work cut out for them as they struggle with competition from newer financial centers such as Dubai, Singapore and Botswana. And like any location struggling with labels such as “tax haven” or “offshore financial center” and their association, fair or not, with images of tax evasion and the laundering of tainted cash, these countries and territories must now deal with the tougher laws and edicts slapped down by international and national authorities.
“The labeling of these countries as tax havens created a lot of negative reaction,” says Trevor Alleyne at the IMF, adding that the greater international scrutiny of money-laundering activities also hurt these centers’ images. “There was a stigma around the fact that they were poorly regulated,” he adds.
In mid-2000 the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), for example, launched an initiative to crack down on money laundering and tax evasion while encouraging greater financial transparency at offshore financial centers around the world. At that time, nearly half of the 35 jurisdictions targeted by the OECD were in the Caribbean. Two years later the Caribbean countries had moved themselves off the hot seat by vowing to help other countries track down tax cheats.
The heat was turned up again after the terrorist attacks on the United States in September 2001, when international organizations and many national governments demanded more diligent tracking of financial flows around the globe. Legislation such as the US Patriot Act affected all financial jurisdictions, not just the Caribbean, as US treasury officials attempted to block funding conduits for terrorists.
Officials in the Caribbean agree that one result of the greater scrutiny was a stronger financial services regulatory regime, more transparent governance and greater adherence to international best practices by corporations operating there. “After the blacklisting, the countries moved to improve their anti-money-laundering regulations,” says Howard Edmonds, financial sector adviser at the Caribbean Regional Technical Assistance Center (Cartec) in Barbados. The countries with larger and more established financial centers, such as the Bahamas, Bermuda, Cayman Islands and Barbados, actually fared well as investors and institutions sought out reliable sources for their investments.
In a move meant to reflect the global shift to more uniform regulation of offshore and onshore financial centers, the IMF in early July dropped the distinction between offshore and onshore financial centers, saying globalization had blurred the distinction. The IMF says it is moving toward a more uniform and risk-based approach to financial sector surveillance.
The Caribbean region’s financial services sector has also been strengthened by the guidance provided through the Caribbean Financial Action Task Force, an organization of 30 Caribbean Basin states created in the early 1990s to establish common measures to counter money laundering.
Edmonds says the more stringent regulations and greater scrutiny have generally made it more difficult, and frequently more expensive, for offshore companies to set up entities in the region. “There are higher standards now,” says Edmonds. “Nobody wants to be associated with lax supervision.”
Daniel Mitchell, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute in Washington, DC, says the development of the financial services sector is crucial for the long-term economic growth of the Caribbean. Too sparsely populated and too far removed from major population centers to make the region a viable manufacturing locale, it has relied on tourism to diversify from agriculture. “Growing sugar cane is not competitive anymore,” says Mitchell, who specializes in tax reform and supply-side tax policy. “And serving piña coladas to tourists isn’t going to produce great wealth for the local population.”
Banks, insurers, insurance captives and hedge funds can boost the local economies through better-paying jobs and tax revenue that can improve the physical infrastructure and develop the human capital with stronger schools, adds Mitchell. Yet at this point only the more developed financial centers, such as the Cayman Islands, Bermuda and Bahamas, have seen the higher-paying jobs in the law, accounting and actuarial fields trickle down to the local populace. “[Financial services] is not a silver bullet, but the sector helps in direct ways, such as jobs and tax revenues,” says Mitchell.
Maharaj: Each financial center needs to offer a unique service.
Several of the smaller Caribbean countries, such as St. Lucia and St. Vincent, were hit by a World Trade Organization ruling opening the banana market to more competition. The recent drop in sugar prices has left only Barbados, which produces rum for export, with a significant sugar industry, notes Turner-Jones.
The islands continue to face other challenges, as well—from the perennial rebuilding after a severe hurricane season, to the more recent soaring costs of fuel and food, both of which must be imported in large quantities.
“The financial sector is on everybody’s mind,” says Turner-Jones. “But officials should also be using their well-educated citizens to develop other industries, such as offshore medical services and investing in technology—not just call centers, but education in technology, as was done in India.”
Even with a limited retail or corporate banking market that dampens the region’s draw for foreign banks, the Caribbean has had its share of foreign banking activity over the past several years. Last year CIBC assumed sole ownership of FirstCaribbean International Bank in Barbados, points out Leonardo Bravo, a credit analyst with the financial ratings group of Standard & Poor’s in Mexico City.
That followed an earlier acquisition of Bank of Bermuda by HSBC in 2004. Bank of Bermuda, which had assets of $10.7 billion at year-end 2007, caters to the island’s wealthy residents, with asset management and trust services. The island’s other large bank is the Bank of N.T. Butterfield, which had assets of $12.3 billion at the end of the second quarter. With 20% annual growth rates, the retail banking sector in Bermuda is experiencing stronger growth than the corporate loan market, which is expanding at 10% to 15%, says Robert Hansen, a credit analyst at S&P;’s financial institutions ratings group in New York. Those rates should slow this year and next, he says, adding that conservative lending policies have allowed Bermudan banks to largely avoid the subprime mortgage crisis hitting banks in the US and Europe.
Bankers agree that the limited size of the Caribbean banking market makes it an unlikely target for future acquisitions by foreign banks. Yet Royal Bank of Canada recently expanded its extensive presence in the region by buying the RBTT Financial Group.
Sealed in June, the $2.2 billion transaction creates one of the largest banking networks in the Caribbean, with operations in 18 countries and territories. The transaction will also mark RBC’s return to Trinidad and Tobago, where it had maintained operations from 1902 to 1987, when it sold off its remaining shares in RBTT. RBC plans to shift its Caribbean headquarters from the Bahamas to Trinidad and Tobago’s capital, Port of Spain, a move that coincides with the country’s efforts to build on its oil and natural gas wealth and develop itself as a financial center for the Caribbean.
A senior executive at Citi sees all international financial centers playing an increasing role in the modern business world as it becomes more global. “But each center needs to offer a unique service,” says Suresh Maharaj, corporate and investment banking head for Citi in Central America and the Caribbean. He says Trinidad and Tobago has played a major role in the development of the region’s capital markets by “raising capital for regional governments and private institutions.”
Michael Cormier, managing director of captive solutions at Marsh, the global insurance broker and risk adviser based in New York City, agrees that offering a unique asset to foreign clients is essential if a country is to thrive as a financial center. Nations such as Bermuda, the Cayman Islands and Barbados that have gained revenue from the captive insurance industry for years have to contend now with competition from about 20 states in the US that have set up legislation to lure captives.
At the same time, North America, the main driver for captives based in the Caribbean, has registered a slow to flat market for new captives over the past three to four years. As of March the number of captives in Bermuda totaled 958, followed by 765 in Cayman and 567 in Vermont, which has had legislation encouraging the growth of the captive market for many years.
“That’s going to be one of the challenges for them—differentiating yourself,” says Cormier. “There are many more options for companies to remain onshore. And there’s not the stigma of going offshore.”
Paula l. Green